HMRC estimates · Direct effects of illustrative tax changes, published 24 Jun 2025
What a change to each tax raises
HMRC publishes what a small change to each tax would raise in a year. These are the changes most talked about before a Budget, one card each to quote and link to: HMRC's figure, the year it is for, the range we show, HMRC's caveat and a link that makes the change in the sandbox.
Of these one-point changes, 1 point on VAT raises the most, in 2026-27 and in 2028-29.
The cards
- 1p on the basic rate of income tax20% to 21%
- 2026-27
- £6.9bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1p on the basic rate of income tax: 6.9bn in 2026-27, 8.2bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £6.2bn to £7.6bn
- 2028-29
- £8.2bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1p on the basic rate of income tax: 6.9bn in 2026-27, 8.2bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £7.4bn to £9bn
- 1p on the higher rate of income tax40% to 41%
- 2026-27
- £1.6bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1p on the higher rate of income tax: 1.6bn in 2026-27, 2.1bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £1.4bn to £1.8bn
- 2028-29
- £2.1bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1p on the higher rate of income tax: 1.6bn in 2026-27, 2.1bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £1.9bn to £2.3bn
- 2026-27
- £5.35bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1 point on the employee NICs main rate: 5.35bn in 2026-27, 5.4bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £4.8bn to £5.9bn
- 2028-29
- £5.4bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1 point on the employee NICs main rate: 5.35bn in 2026-27, 5.4bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £4.9bn to £5.9bn
- 1 point on VAT20% to 21%
- 2026-27
- £8.8bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1 point on the standard rate of VAT: 8.8bn in 2026-27, 9.55bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £7.9bn to £9.7bn
- 2028-29
- £9.55bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1 point on the standard rate of VAT: 8.8bn in 2026-27, 9.55bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £8.6bn to £10.5bn
- 1 point on corporation tax25% to 26%
- 2026-27
- £3.6bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1 point on the main rate of corporation tax: 3.6bn in 2026-27, 4bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £3.2bn to £4bn
- 2028-29
- £4bnSourcedHMRC direct effect of 1 point on the main rate of corporation tax: 3.6bn in 2026-27, 4bn by 2028-29 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range £3.6bn to £4.4bn
- A rise in capital gains taxHigher rate +1 point, 24% to 25%; more rises on the card
- 2026-27
- −£15mSourcedHMRC's estimates for raising the higher rate of capital gains tax, with the change made at the start of 2026-27 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). +1 point: −£15m in 2026-27, −£30m in 2028-29; +5 points: −£170m in 2026-27, −£870m in 2028-29; +10 points: −£540m in 2026-27, −£3,565m in 2028-29. A minus means the Treasury collects less: HMRC's figures allow for people selling fewer assets when the rate rises. These are HMRC's only steps (+1, +5, +10 points), so the sandbox offers no others and never scales or blends them: HMRC says its capital gains tax figures “are also non-linear and so cannot be scaled up”. Taxing these gains at the higher rate of income tax (40% in England, Wales and Northern Ireland) would need a rise of 16 points, bigger than any HMRC estimates. Starting rate 24%, the rate for 2026-27 (GOV.UK). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range −£17m to −£14m
- 2028-29
- −£30mSourcedHMRC's estimates for raising the higher rate of capital gains tax, with the change made at the start of 2026-27 (HMRC-DE-2025-06). +1 point: −£15m in 2026-27, −£30m in 2028-29; +5 points: −£170m in 2026-27, −£870m in 2028-29; +10 points: −£540m in 2026-27, −£3,565m in 2028-29. A minus means the Treasury collects less: HMRC's figures allow for people selling fewer assets when the rate rises. These are HMRC's only steps (+1, +5, +10 points), so the sandbox offers no others and never scales or blends them: HMRC says its capital gains tax figures “are also non-linear and so cannot be scaled up”. Taxing these gains at the higher rate of income tax (40% in England, Wales and Northern Ireland) would need a rise of 16 points, bigger than any HMRC estimates. Starting rate 24%, the rate for 2026-27 (GOV.UK). Low–high is an editorial ±10% because HMRC publishes a central figure only. HMRC includes taxpayers' own behavioural response where it models one, but no wider economic effects.HMRC: Direct effects of illustrative tax changes
- range −£33m to −£27m
Each figure is HMRC's, for a change made at the start of 2026-27, on its own. The range is 10% either side, our usual band where a source gives none. A minus is a net loss: HMRC expects less tax, not more.
How these figures work
Where do these figures come from?
From HMRC's Direct effects of illustrative tax changes, the edition published 24 Jun 2025, the latest. HMRC works out what a small change to each tax would raise, for a change made at the start of 2026-27, using the official forecast of the time. The sandbox on this site uses the same figures.
Why is each figure shown with a range?
HMRC publishes one figure for each year. Anything forecast on this site is shown as a range, so we put 10% either side of HMRC's figure, our usual band where a source gives no range of its own. Quote HMRC's figure as HMRC's.
Can I double the figure for a 2p rise?
For most tax rates, yes, as a rough guide: HMRC says a 2p change raises or costs around twice as much as 1p. Not for capital gains tax, where HMRC says its figures cannot be scaled, so each card shows only the rises HMRC costs.
Do the figures allow for how people respond?
Mostly, yes. HMRC includes taxpayers' own responses where it models them, such as reporting less income or selling fewer assets. It leaves out wider effects on the economy, such as on prices, jobs or growth, which the Office for Budget Responsibility judges when a change is announced.
Is this what the Budget will raise?
No. These are HMRC's illustrations of a single change, made on their own. A real Budget measure is costed by the Treasury and checked by the Office for Budget Responsibility, and can differ, because it starts at another date, comes with other changes, or the forecast has moved.
Try any change, or several together, in the sandbox; see how the numbers are made.